Our Story
From college bar to Tiffin's favorite restaurant
Our Journey
Owner Chris Chase (Tiffin University '03, '05) purchased Madison Street Tavern in 2009 and transformed it from a late-night college hangout to a family-friendly restaurant.
Over 15+ years, Chris has been a servant leader — often found cooking, taking orders, or greeting guests personally.
Our Mission
Quality food, exceptional service, lasting relationships
We pride ourselves on offering fresh, quality food at affordable prices. Our goal is to provide exceptional service and a great dining experience worth coming back for. We like to treat our customers like family.
Family atmosphere and community focus
M$T Sauce Company
Bring Home the Tastes Made Famous on Madison Street
Our housemade sauces are bottled and sold throughout the region. Multiple sauce flavors including blazing garlic parm, created in-house and continuously refined. Available for purchase to take home.
Shop SaucesAwards & Recognition
#1 Restaurant in Tiffin
TripAdvisor ranking out of 43 restaurants
Restaurant Guru 2023
Award recipient
America's Best Restaurants
Featured restaurant
4.8/5 Rating
Across all platforms
100/100 Health Score
Perfect health inspection